Decision guide
How to evaluate a hardwood flooring quote in Toronto
How do I tell a good hardwood flooring quote from a bad one?
Six questions that separate a company that has done the diligence from one that intends to discover the problems after your deposit has cleared. Any "no" is a red flag.
First
What actually decides this
Was anything measured before the price was set?
A price quoted without moisture readings and a substrate assessment is an estimate of a building nobody has examined.
Is the price closed or open?
Open-ended change-order language transfers the cost of missing diligence onto the homeowner, after commitment.
Who actually performs the work?
A crew that will not be there next season has no stake in how the floor performs next season.
Decide
The decision tree, in the order we walk it
- Do they moisture-test at the free estimate, and document the readings? → If no, stop here.
- Do they require a minimum 72-hour acclimation in the actual space? → If no, the warranty is decorative.
- Is the price fixed in writing, with no open-ended change-order language? → If no, the quoted number is not the price.
- Are the installers salaried employees, or day-labour subcontractors?
- Will they refuse the job if the substrate or conditions are wrong?
- Is there true lifetime workmanship warranty language in the contract itself?
Answer
What we recommend
Run all six against every quote you hold, including ours. The self-assessment scores the full twenty-four-criterion framework and tells you which questions to go back and ask.
- Any company that cannot or will not provide these is optimizing for speed and lowest bid, not for decades of performance.
Also asked
Related questions this guide answers
- What should a hardwood flooring quote include?
- The moisture readings and the date they were taken, the species, grade and width, the subfloor preparation, the installation method and why, the grit sequence, the finish product and number of coats, stairs and transitions itemised, the schedule, and the workmanship warranty language in the contract itself rather than on a website. A quote missing the moisture readings was priced before anyone knew what the job was.
- How do I know if a hardwood contractor uses subcontractors?
- Ask who is on payroll and get the answer in writing. The question matters because a protocol can be requested of a subcontracted crew and required of a salaried one, and because a workmanship warranty is only meaningful from a company that still controls the people whose workmanship it covers when you call.
Most searched in Toronto
Hardwood flooring in Toronto
Installation and refinishing, with the price bands published before you call. New hardwood installed runs $11.00–$18.00 per square foot.
Hardwood floor refinishing in Toronto
Dust-free sanding in an occupied home. A full sand and finish runs $4.75–$7.50 per square foot; a screen and recoat $2.50–$4.00 where the existing finish is sound.
Hardwood stairs in Toronto
Refinishing, carpet removal and new treads, matched to the floor they meet. Quoted per tread rather than per square foot, and itemised in the written price rather than added to it later.
Floor already cupping, gapping or lifting? What your floor is telling you gives each symptom its cause and an honest prognosis — including the two where the answer is to do nothing yet.
Judging quotes rather than buying yet? The Well-Installed Framework sets out 27 criteria, published free to use on any contractor in the GTA — including us — or score a quote you already have.
Provenance
Where every claim on this page comes from
- The Intelligent Homeowner's Decision Framework — installer checklist
- Climate Mastery — what to demand
- The Intelligent Homeowner's Decision Framework — fixed price
Framework pillars this bears on
Once this is decided
What the work actually is
Hardwood Flooring Installation · Hardwood Floor Refinishing · Dust-Free Floor Sanding · Hardwood Floor Restoration · Custom Inlays & Borders · Stair Refinishing
Prices for all three bands are published before you call — hardwood flooring in Toronto for a new floor, refinishing for an existing one, stairs for the part usually left out of the quote. If the floor is already cupping, gapping or lifting, this is a diagnosis rather than a decision: what your floor is telling you.
Proof, with the numbers
Where these decisions were made on real jobs
Each publishes the readings and the reasoning, not only the result — which is what makes them worth reading next to a guide rather than instead of one.
Distillery District, over concrete
Over a concrete slab: the moisture test decided the assembly before a species was chosen.
Rosedale estate, stairs over radiant heat
Radiant heat under a main floor and a staircase, with the thermal range designed for.
Forest Hill, wide-plank walnut
Wide-plank walnut, and keeping the colour uniform across boards that age photochemically.
Every case study publishes what was measured, not only what was achieved — all of them are here, and each one names the substrate, the species, the readings and the protocol it followed.
Next
More decision guides
Solid or engineered hardwood
Should I install solid or engineered hardwood in my Toronto home?
Decision guideNail-down, glue-down or floating
Which hardwood installation method is correct for my subfloor?
Decision guideHardwood flooring cost in Toronto
How much does hardwood flooring cost in Toronto and the GTA?
Decision guideHow to choose a hardwood contractor in Toronto
How do I choose a hardwood flooring contractor in Toronto?
Decision guideWhite oak flooring in Toronto
Is white oak the right hardwood for a Toronto home?
Decision guideHerringbone, chevron and parquet in Toronto
Should I install herringbone, chevron or parquet in my Toronto home or condo?
Next step
I have quotes. Is this one fair?
That is what this page is for. When you are ready to move, this is the next thing worth doing — not a quote, unless a quote is what you came for.
Score the quote you are leaning toward, criterion by criterion