Black walnut hardwood flooring in Toronto — the scarcest floor in the market

Specification

The assembled specification

Botanical name

Juglans nigra

Side hardness, 12% MC

1,010 lbf — the softest of the six (USDA Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook Table 5-3b)

Ontario range

Common in moist, low-lying areas in Southwestern Ontario, often planted north and east of its range (Ontario Tree Atlas)

Ontario commercial status

Not among the seven principal tolerant hardwoods; Ontario lists its wood use as high quality furniture and veneer

US growing stock

1.0% of the US total, 139.3 million m³ — the scarcest of the six (American Hardwood Export Council)

US annual growth against harvest

4.8 million m³ grown against 1.9 million m³ harvested per year

Flooring grades published

Clear, Select, No. 1 Common, No. 2 Common (NWFA/NOFMA black walnut rules); No. 1 Common requires heartwood to be a minimum of 25% of the piece

Failure modes

Where this goes wrong

• At 1,010 lbf, walnut dents. That is not a defect and it is not a reason to avoid it — it is a reason to be explicit about it before the floor is bought, particularly in a household with dogs, chairs on hard castors or a piano.
• Ontario names walnut’s wood use as furniture and veneer, not flooring. The species is present in the province; the flooring supply is a different market, and the volume behind it is one percent of the US growing stock.
• Walnut’s heartwood is what people are buying. The NWFA/NOFMA rules set a minimum heartwood proportion only at No. 1 Common and below — at 25% of the piece — so the grade named on the quote materially changes what arrives.

Answer

What we recommend

Walnut is the correct specification where colour and depth outrank dent resistance and the client has heard the hardness number before choosing. Engineered walnut over a stable core is frequently the better assembly, because the wear layer is the part that has to be walnut.

• State the 1,010 lbf hardness figure in the proposal, in writing, before the deposit.
• For a high-traffic household, compare against white oak at 1,360 lbf in the same finish before deciding.

Also asked

Related questions this guide answers

Does black walnut flooring dent easily?

More easily than any other species commonly sold here. The USDA Forest Products Laboratory publishes black walnut at 1,010 lbf side hardness at 12% moisture content, against hickory at 1,880 and hard maple at 1,450. It is a floor chosen for its colour and depth, and it should be specified with that trade-off stated out loud.

Why is walnut flooring so expensive?

Scarcity, on the published inventory. The American Hardwood Export Council records black walnut at 1.0% of the US hardwood growing stock — 139.3 million cubic metres against red oak’s 2.62 billion — with an annual harvest of 1.9 million cubic metres. It is the smallest resource of the six by an order of magnitude, and price follows.

Is walnut flooring sustainable?

On the published resource figures, black walnut grows faster than it is cut: 4.8 million cubic metres of annual growth against 1.9 million harvested. Scarcity here is a matter of how little exists, not of overcutting. As with every species, the resource figure says nothing about an individual supply chain — for that, ask who milled it.

Provenance

Where every claim on this page comes from

• Provenance — tolerant hardwoods
• Provenance — ash
• Grade — nwfa appearance

Framework pillars this bears on

• Pillar 3 — Product specification

Once this is decided

What the work actually is

Hardwood Flooring Installation · Hardwood Floor Refinishing · Dust-Free Floor Sanding · Hardwood Floor Restoration · Custom Inlays & Borders · Stair Refinishing

Prices for all three bands are published before you call — hardwood flooring in Toronto for a new floor, refinishing for an existing one, stairs for the part usually left out of the quote. If the floor is already cupping, gapping or lifting, this is a diagnosis rather than a decision: what your floor is telling you.

Proof, with the numbers

Where these decisions were made on real jobs

Each publishes the readings and the reasoning, not only the result — which is what makes them worth reading next to a guide rather than instead of one.

Every case study publishes what was measured, not only what was achieved — all of them are here, and each one names the substrate, the species, the readings and the protocol it followed.

Next

More reference installations